Difference between revisions of "Talk:Grrrls Riot"
From ZineWiki
Jump to navigationJump to searchDan10things (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
* '''Delete.''' Obviously not formatted or written for an encyclopedia. [[User:Alanlastufka|Alan Fall of Autumn]] 10:12, 30 November 2006 (EST) | * '''Delete.''' Obviously not formatted or written for an encyclopedia. [[User:Alanlastufka|Alan Fall of Autumn]] 10:12, 30 November 2006 (EST) | ||
** '''Delete''' Ditto to what Alan said. If it were a zine title, or something published to be possibly quoted in the main Riot Grrrl entry, I'd feel differently. But it's just "one opinion" and it was written like a letter or e-mail. While some of it looked awfully familiar, a lot of stuff written about riot grrrl looks awfully familiar, cos the same phrases and ideas get recycled A LOT. My, this site is becoming a magnet for bored people (says the chick who started adding to the site cos she was bored, but at least I respect the concept and the boundaries of this wiki). [[User: sarah]] 30 November 2006, 12:45pm EST | ** '''Delete''' Ditto to what Alan said. If it were a zine title, or something published to be possibly quoted in the main Riot Grrrl entry, I'd feel differently. But it's just "one opinion" and it was written like a letter or e-mail. While some of it looked awfully familiar, a lot of stuff written about riot grrrl looks awfully familiar, cos the same phrases and ideas get recycled A LOT. My, this site is becoming a magnet for bored people (says the chick who started adding to the site cos she was bored, but at least I respect the concept and the boundaries of this wiki). [[User: sarah]] 30 November 2006, 12:45pm EST | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''Delete''' This is an editorial, it's not a zine resource, it was clearly added by someone that doesn't understand what a Wiki is. Plus we have a fairly good history of riot grrrl and riot grrrl zines in more substantive listings. [[User:Dan10things|dan10things]] 13:12, 30 November 2006 (EST) | ||
Latest revision as of 18:12, 30 November 2006
- Delete. Obviously not formatted or written for an encyclopedia. Alan Fall of Autumn 10:12, 30 November 2006 (EST)
- Delete Ditto to what Alan said. If it were a zine title, or something published to be possibly quoted in the main Riot Grrrl entry, I'd feel differently. But it's just "one opinion" and it was written like a letter or e-mail. While some of it looked awfully familiar, a lot of stuff written about riot grrrl looks awfully familiar, cos the same phrases and ideas get recycled A LOT. My, this site is becoming a magnet for bored people (says the chick who started adding to the site cos she was bored, but at least I respect the concept and the boundaries of this wiki). User: sarah 30 November 2006, 12:45pm EST
Delete This is an editorial, it's not a zine resource, it was clearly added by someone that doesn't understand what a Wiki is. Plus we have a fairly good history of riot grrrl and riot grrrl zines in more substantive listings. dan10things 13:12, 30 November 2006 (EST)
