Yard Sale! #1 was published in late May 2009 and included interviews with the dancehall duo Bonjay, David Barclay of indiepop bands The Endless Bummer and The Diskettes and Kristin Cheung of the website papercubs.com, in addition to comics, reviews, games, and more.
Yard Sale! #2 launched late August 2009 at Toronto's Zine Dream 2 zine fair. The zine featured similar content and tone to the first issue including interviews with Daps Duo and Emma Ditchburn of The Most Serene Republic.
Yard Sale! #3 was released in mid-November 2009 and features a shift from half-page to quarter-page sizing and an increased focus on perzine material over fanzine. For the first time, the zine boasts a full-color cover and has writing about baking, Canzine, cold weather, and failed bicycle rides. A free photograph is included for anyone who buys a copy.
Yard Sale! #4 will be available sometime in February 2010.